| Winner | Year |
|---|---|
| 2024 | |
| William M But”lic”ker | 2023 |
| Cry Me a Phillip Rivers | 2022 |
| Momma Roinas | 2021 |
| Freak Beast Henry | 2020 |
| Take Mahome Tonight | 2019 |
| The Lynch Who Stole Christmas | 2018 |
| Cry Me a Phillip Rivers | 2017 |
| The Lynch Who Stole Christmas | 2016 |
| Every Play I’m Russelin’ | 2015 |
| Miller Time | 2014 |
| Cry Me a Phillip Rivers | 2013 |
| The Lynch That Stole Christmas | 2012 |
| Plain Bagel | 2011 |
| Warcraft of Seattle | 2010 |
| Shake N’ Bake | 2009 |